modernmonkeymind

I’ve been watching all of the star trek shows from the beginning of Next Generation through Discovery. I’m at the beginning of Voyager at the moment and just saw Tuvok use his com badge to talk to an officer on the other side of the bridge. Haven’t seen this before, and strikes me as a bit weird. I love Star Trek, but I’m not as knowledgeable about the mythos as I’d like. Curious as to why Tuvok would have used his com badge for this purpose (it was to reprimand an officer for an off hand comment). Since the com badges seem to be recording devices as well (we see officers take them off plenty of times to have conversations “off the record”) could this be a way of kind of highlighting this exchange to formalize the reprimand, or is there something else going on?

trekcore

Interesting. I never took the removal of the communicator as a deactivation of it, rather as a symbolic gesture. At the time it was made, we couldn’t yet envision our “always listening” technology, so I wonder if the writers did? Regardless it’s interesting to see that be the thought process of today.

spockvarietyhour

I’ll add a layer here: I recently rewatched Inter Arma Enim Silent Leges, there’s a scene towards the end where Bashir goes to see Ross after Sloane appears to have been vaporized. Before they start this conversation Ross states its going to be off the record and both remove their combadges. There’s a little digital audio click sound too as they remove them, signaling they might be off?

Star TrekTNGDS9VoyagerCombadgesInconsistent use of technology is nothing new to scifi or star trek*coughthreeshotzatguncouch*

202 notes

  1. spiderfluids reblogged this from spockvarietyhour
  2. countsunflower reblogged this from startrekstartrash
  3. darkestday828 reblogged this from startrekstartrash
  4. lizzyandtheanxiety reblogged this from data-sweet-potata
  5. data-sweet-potata reblogged this from casual-space-plant
  6. thisusernameisunique reblogged this from gaseous-anomalies and added:
    I have no problem imagining two bridge officers using their combadges to talk. It could correlate to two people texting...
  7. casual-space-plant reblogged this from gaseous-anomalies
  8. demonicapex reblogged this from startrekstartrash
  9. pizzaheathen reblogged this from gaseous-anomalies
  10. gaseous-anomalies reblogged this from star-temeraire
  11. silkw0rm reblogged this from startrekstartrash
  12. startrekstartrash reblogged this from star-temeraire
  13. star-temeraire reblogged this from thisisstarfleet
  14. setacourse4home reblogged this from reasonably-annoyed-fog
  15. modernmonkeymind posted this