Rating DS9 Comics by How Well They Draw Julian Bashir
sigynpenniman
TNG/DS9 Divided We Fall #2 (Wildstorm Comics)
This is fine, I guess. It’s not good, but I’m not personally offended by it. I appreciate the shiny anime eyes, but that is not Julian’s skintone (which will be a common theme.) 4/10 do better
The Q Conflict #4 (IDW)
The point of this series is that crews are pulled out of their own time - generally about the same time we knew them - and pulled into a sort of nether dimension. So why is Julian a full commander here. I’m all for promoting the boy but the crews in this series are meant to be from about the same time we knew them - note the teal shoulders. The face is…I’ve seen worse. More anime eyes and another bad case of whitewashing. +1 for being more pleasant art but -2 for whitewashing and bad rank research. 4/10.
Star Trek DS9 #3 (Marvel/Paramount)
WHO THE FUCK IS THIS. +1 I guess for him not being white but there is nothing acceptable about that face. 2/10.
Star Trek DS9 #27 (Malibu)
Bonus points for actually making him cute but minus a couple again for making him cute like a 1940s movie star and not like, well, Sid. I don’t like this but it doesn’t horrify my soul. 5/10 I guess.
Star Trek DS9: Fool’s Gold #2 (IDW)
You know what? I don’t hate this. There’s a certain aesthetic value that does seem to be present. Skin tone is okay. Let’s not talk about what they’ve done to Sisko, though. 6/10.
Star Trek: Waypoint #3 (IDW)
IT’S CUTE! It’s not an exact likeness, but it’s cartoony in a pleasing and cute way instead of being awful. +many points for getting the nose and skintone right. 9/10.
Star Trek DS9 #6 (Malibu)
WHO AND WHAT IS THIS UGLY WHITE MAN. 0/10. I AM ANGRY.
Star Trek DS9 Too Long a Sacrifice #1 (IDW)
The top panel is so much worse than the bottom one it’s hard to judge this fairly. This art almost feels like a weird filter over a screenshot. I kind of hate it, even though it’s not the most inaccurate. 3/10 because I hate it for no good reason.
Star Trek Special: Flesh and Stone (IDW)
This is another one that feels like it was traced, maybe? But traced badly. There’s features of his face that really make me feel like they traced this but just did a poor job of it. It does actually sort of look like Sid, though. 6/10.
Star Trek DS9 #18c/ Maquis: Soldier of Peace
Hey what the fuck. WHAT THE FUCK. I can’t say anything about the face because I’m looking at those pecs. What is this nonsense. 1/10 never draw Julian again please whoever drew this.
Star Trek: The Q Gambit
THE FACE! THE NOSE! THE GENTLE SPARKLE IN THE EYES! I think these are traced too but they’re so so pretty I don’t care. This is a Julian I want to kiss on the cheek. Look at that smile in the top panel! THAT’S MY BOY. 1000000/10.
Star Trek DS9: N-Vector #1 (Wildstorm)
(HORRIFIED SCREAMING)
-214,597,479/10
a-stitch-in-time-and-space
I love that you saved the best and the worst for last, it was like being softly hugged only to suddenly receive a massive fish slapped into my face
